College
HOOPSDATA
  • Home
  • Team Stats
  • Team Analytics
  • Player Stats
  • Player Analytics
  • Recruiting
  • Transfer Portal
  • Coaching Carousel
  • Articles
Privacy·Terms·About
HomeTeamsArticlesRecruitsPortalCoaches
Privacy·Terms·About

Rankings & Stats

  • NET Rankings
  • Team Stats
  • Player Stats

Conferences

  • ACC
  • Big Ten
  • Big 12
  • SEC
  • Big East
  • AAC

Tools

  • Team Analytics
  • Player Analytics
  • Recruiting
  • Transfer Portal
  • Coaching Carousel

Learn

  • All Guides
  • NET Rankings Guide
  • Efficiency Ratings Guide
  • NIL & Athlete Pay Guide
  • Transfer Portal Guide
AboutPrivacy PolicyTerms of UseDisclaimerContact

© 2024-2026 College Hoops Data. All rights reserved.

College
HOOPSDATA

Articles

Articles

  1. Home
  2. /Articles
  3. /Dusty May Ruined His Own Leverage. Michigan Is Paying Him $40 Million Anyway.
All articles
Coaching Carousel

Dusty May Ruined His Own Leverage. Michigan Is Paying Him $40 Million Anyway.

He told Warde Manuel mid-tournament he wasn't taking another job. Then he won the national title and the AD paid him anyway.

By Brian Coleman·Apr 18, 2026·6 min read
MichiganMichigan
Dusty May Ruined His Own Leverage. Michigan Is Paying Him $40 Million Anyway.

A Standing Ovation, A Punchline, A Pay Raise

Warde Manuel grabbed a mic at Crisler Center on Saturday and told the crowd that he and Dusty May had "already reached an agreement." The chant of "Dusty!" started in the lower bowl and spread upward. Manuel waited for it to die down, then said May would be Michigan's coach "for many years to come."

Then May took the mic and delivered the funniest line of the entire 2026 carousel.

"I'm very grateful," he said. "And during the tournament, I just told Warde I'm not leaving. And I probably ruined any leverage I could have had."

That was the whole press conference. A coach who'd just won a national title joking about costing himself money by being honest. The new contract is five years through 2030-31, with the dollar figures still being finalized per Tony Garcia of the Detroit Free Press. May had been making $3.75 million per year on the deal Michigan handed him in 2024. The new number is expected to land at or above $8.5 million annually — same neighborhood as Bill Self at Kansas and Michael Malone at North Carolina.

That's roughly $40 million guaranteed for a guy who told his AD he was staying before he won the title.

What He Walked Away From

The 2026 carousel was the most expensive in college basketball history. North Carolina handed Malone a six-year, $50 million contract on April 6 — the same day May beat UConn for the title. LSU gave Will Wade seven years and $30 million to come back from McNeese after firing Matt McMahon. Providence committed $10 million in NIL on top of Bryan Hodgson's contract to poach him from a one-year run at South Florida. NC State tore up its checkbook to land Justin Gainey on a five-year, $12.75 million deal after Wade took the LSU job. Belmont's Casey Alexander got $17 million over five at Kansas State. The base price of being a power-conference head coach jumped a tier in the span of three weeks.

May had Carolina. Or at least Carolina had him in the holding pattern, which this carousel was the same thing.

ESPN's Pete Thamel and Jeff Borzello reported on April 5 that May had told everyone involved he wasn't pursuing any college basketball jobs. Matt Norlander at CBS Sports got the same word the same weekend. UNC had been waiting since Arizona's Tommy Lloyd extended on April 3 — a $7.5 million per year deal that was its own statement about leverage in the Lloyd-vs-UNC negotiation. T.J. Otzelberger at Iowa State had passed. Brad Stevens was, per the reporting, a pipe dream. May was the last realistic name on the board.

He communicated the rejection over a weekend in which Michigan was preparing for the Final Four against Arizona. He'd ducked the question every time it came up in March, the way coaches in his position do — you don't kill a payday until you have to. By the Sunday before the championship game, the answer was no.

UNC hired Malone the next day.

Key Takeaway

Anti-Carousel: stayed put, won the ring, got Self money

“

during the tournament, I just told Warde I'm not leaving. And I probably ruined any leverage I could have had

Dusty Mayat Michigan's championship celebration, April 11, 2026

The Carolina Pitch That Wasn't

Three weeks ago, when Hubert Davis was getting fired in Chapel Hill and Bubba Cunningham was calling the agents of every name on Carolina's wishlist, May was the consensus answer. CBS Sports listed him as the top target. HoopsHQ had him second behind Lloyd. ESPN's coaching board had him ahead of Donovan, Stackhouse and any Jay Wright comeback fantasy.

Carolina is supposed to win those fights. The Smith Center, the brand, the Roy Williams endorsement machine — that was the package. Carolina recruited May the way Carolina recruits everybody: the assumption that you say yes.

He said no while his team was 64-13 over two seasons under him, the fastest to 50 wins in Michigan history. He said no after taking an 8-24 program — Juwan Howard's last roster, the worst Michigan team in two decades — and rebuilding it through the portal in 18 months. He said no with a roster that finished 37-3 and beat UConn for the title.

"When you've taken a school as prominent and powerful as Michigan to the final night of the season in just two years, what's the point in leaving?" Norlander wrote.

That's the question Carolina didn't have an answer to.

What the Title Looked Like

The championship game itself was tight, ugly, and decided at the line. Michigan beat UConn 69-63 at Lucas Oil Stadium in front of 70,720 fans. The Wolverines shot 38.2% from the floor and 2-of-13 from three. They went 25-of-28 at the line.

Elliot Cadeau was named Final Four Most Outstanding Player. He went for 19 points, 3 rebounds, 2 assists and 2 steals in the title game and hit the only Michigan three of the first half. Yaxel Lendeborg added 13. Morez Johnson Jr. had 12 and 10 with two blocks against the UConn frontline of Tarris Reed Jr. and Alex Karaban.

UConn led at halftime. UConn led with five minutes left. Then Michigan started getting calls. Twenty-five free throws to UConn's eight is the kind of disparity that ends games, especially when the team scoring 25 of them shoots 38% from the floor. Trey McKenney hit a three with 1:50 left to push the Michigan lead to nine, and that was the game. Dan Hurley couldn't get a stop or a foul-shot bailout the rest of the way.

Michigan's first national title since 1989. Thirty-seven years between cuts of the net. The longest drought in program history finally over with a coach Michigan got out of FAU on a five-year, $18.75 million deal that already looks like the steal of the decade.

What the 2026 Carousel Actually Bought

Dusty May (Michigan)Michael Malone (UNC)
Annual Salary (est.)$8.5M+$8.3M ($50M / 6yr)
2025-26 ResultNational ChampionDid Not Coach (ESPN)
Career College HC Wins1900
Years Since School Won a TitleJust won one32

The Path There

May took 8-24 and last in the Big Ten and went 27-10 his first season. He took 27-10 and went 37-3 his second. The tournament path: Howard 101-80, St. Louis 95-72, Alabama 90-77, Tennessee 95-62, then Arizona in the Final Four. Nobody got within 13 of Michigan until UConn played them keep-away in the title game.

The roster that did it had zero starters who began their careers at Michigan. All five came through the portal in May's two seasons — Cadeau from North Carolina, Lendeborg from UAB, Johnson from Illinois, Aday Mara from UCLA, with the only true freshman starter being McKenney. May has been clearer about his philosophy than any coach in college basketball.

"Retention is not always good," he told CNN before the Final Four. "It's retaining the right guys."

That's the philosophy that built the title team. It's also about to get tested. Mara is a projected first-round pick. Johnson is borderline first round. Cadeau and McKenney have already announced they're returning. JP Estrella from Tennessee is the first portal commit of the new cycle. The roster May gets to defend with is going to look different from the one that won.

May is 49 years old, born in Terre Haute, Indiana. He spent two years as a student manager for Bob Knight at Indiana, three years as an administrative assistant at Southern Cal, then ground his way through assistant jobs at Eastern Michigan, Murray State, UAB, Louisiana Tech and Florida. He didn't get a head job until Florida Atlantic hired him at age 41. He went 126-69 in six years at FAU — a Final Four in 2023 as a 9-seed, beating Memphis, Fairleigh Dickinson, Tennessee and Kansas State before losing to San Diego State on a Lamont Butler buzzer-beater. Michigan hired him a year later for $3.75 million annually. Two years later he's a national champion at $8.5-plus.

His son Charlie transferred from UCF to Michigan last summer. His youngest, Eli, is a team manager. His oldest, Jack, played four years at Florida. May has built his career on the kind of family-first program that doesn't exist when you take the North Carolina job and inherit a roster you didn't recruit. That probably mattered more in the decision than anyone wants to admit.

The Money, Honestly

May's total compensation in 2025-26 was about $5.1 million — $4.6 million base plus $500,000 in performance bonuses for the regular-season title ($50,000), Big Ten Coach of the Year ($50,000) and the championship ($400,000). That's still bottom-half pay among power-conference coaches. The new deal corrects it.

Self at Kansas is at roughly $9 million. Lloyd's new Arizona extension is $7.5 million. Malone's UNC contract averages $8.3 million. Kelvin Sampson at Houston is in that same band. May lands in the same neighborhood — not because Manuel had to outbid Carolina anymore, but because that's what it costs to keep a national champion two years into a five-year deal who just turned down the only job better than the one he has.

"He will be the leader of this basketball team for many years to come," Manuel said at Crisler.

The five years through 2030-31 is probably conservative. Michigan structured the original 2024 deal with built-in flexibility, and they used that flexibility within 24 months. If May wins another one, they'll do it again.

What Comes Next

Michigan plays at the World University Games in July with three returning players already locked in — Cadeau, McKenney and Estrella. May will spend April working portal commitments while waiting on Mara and Johnson NBA Draft decisions. The Big Ten preseason poll will probably have Michigan No. 1.

The 2026-27 season starts as defending national champion for the first time since 1990. The bar is now Indianapolis again.

May said the night they cut down the nets that this was "the epitome of it all." He told his wife Anna that in the locker room. He told Crisler Center five days later, "this trophy is yours." That's about as much sentiment as he gives on the record.

Then he ruined his leverage and signed for $40 million.

Michigan opens 2026-27 ranked No. 1.

View Transfer Portal Tracker →

More to Read

View all